Mushroom Pop, Mini - Cute Handmade Small Fidget Mushroom Stuffed Animal Keychain - 99% Coffee - #color_Teal

Mushroom Pop Stuffed Animal

$8.00
+3
Customizable Loaf Cat Plushie, Tuxedo - Cute Handmade Custom Cat Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_group

Tuxedo Loaf Cat Stuffed Animal

$19.00
Whale Plushie, Mini - Cute Handmade Small Whale Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_group

Whale Stuffed Animal

$8.00
Manta Ray Plushie - Cute Handmade Sting Ray Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_group

Manta Ray Stuffed Animal

$13.00
Customizable Loaf Cat Plushie, Solid - Cute Handmade Custom Cat Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_group

Loaf Cat Stuffed Animal

$19.00
+1
Shark Plushie, Mini - Cute Handmade Small Shark Stuffed Animal Keychain - 99% Coffee - #color_group

Shark Stuffed Animal

$8.00
Customizable Loaf Cat Plushie, Siamese - Cute Handmade Custom Cat Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_group

Siamese Loaf Cat Stuffed Animal

$19.00
+1
Customizable Loaf Cat Plushie, Tabby - Cute Handmade Custom Cat Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_group

Build a Custom Cat Plushie

Choose your coat pattern, eye color, and name to create your own custom kitty!

Build Now
Customizable Loaf Cat Plushie, Tabby - Cute Handmade Custom Cat Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_group

Tabby Loaf Cat Stuffed Animal

$19.00
+1
Chubby Axolotl Stuffed Animal - Cute Handmade Small Axolotl Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_blue

Chubby Axolotl Stuffed Animal

$15.00
Whale Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee

Whale Stuffed Animal

$11.00
Chubby Mallard Duck Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee

Chubby Mallard Duck Stuffed Animal

$15.00
New
Mini Kiwi Turtle Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee

Kiwi Turtle Stuffed Animal

$15.00
New
Chipmunk Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee

Chipmunk Stuffed Animal

$10.00
New
Flower Jellyfish Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee

Jellyfish Stuffed Animal

$25.00
New
Hedgehog Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee

Hedgehog Stuffed Animal

$24.00
Fall 2025
Pumpkin Cat Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee

Pumpkin Cat Stuffed Animal

$35.00
New
River Otter Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee

River Otter Stuffed Animal

$50.00
Fall 2025
Mini Apple Turtle Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee

Apple Turtle Stuffed Animal

$15.00
Customizable Loaf Cat Plushie, Calico - Handmade Custom Cat Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_white

Calico Loaf Cat Stuffed Animal

$19.00

Handmade Stuffed Animals

From adorable cats and whales to magical dragons and unicorns, there's truly something for everyone!

All stuffed animals are, unless otherwise stated:

  • Handcrafted in Illinois, U.S. and shipped from Sycamore
  • Made solely by Savannah on a one-by-one basis (find out more about Savannah on the about page!)
  • Made with Premium 100% Polyester
  • Filled with super soft, squishy Polyfill
  • Shipped in compostable envelope mailers (smaller items) or recyclable boxes (larger items) with 100% recyclable packing materials 
  • Customizable with different eye options (standard vs. safety eyes), unless otherwise specified and name options, or even more!

Shop the Market

Check out some of the previous market events!

Small Brontosaurus Stuffed Animal - Handmade Dinosaur Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_pink
99% Coffee @ Let's Get Lit Night Market in Rochelle, Illinois hosted by the Artists' Garden