New
Chipmunk Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee

Chipmunk Plushie

$10.00
New
Flower Jellyfish Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee

Jellyfish Plushie

$25.00
New
Hedgehog Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee

Hedgehog Plushie

$24.00
Fall 2025
Pumpkin Cat Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee

Pumpkin Cat Plushie

$35.00
New
River Otter Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee

River Otter Plushie

$50.00
Fall 2025
Mini Apple Turtle Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee

Mini Apple Turtle Plushie

$15.00
Customizable Loaf Cat Plushie, Calico - Handmade Custom Cat Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_classic

Chubby Calico Loaf Cat Plushie

$19.00
Mini Strawberry Turtle Stuffed Animal - Cute Handmade Small Fruit Turtle Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_strawberry

Mini Strawberry Turtle Plushie

$15.00
Updated
Baby Elephant Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee

Baby Elephant Plushie

$27.00
Shark Plushie, Small - Cute Handmade Small Shark Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_grey

Shark Plushie

$11.00
New
White - Belly Tabby Loaf Cat Plushie - 99% Coffee

White-Belly Tabby Loaf Cat Plushie

$19.00
Fall 2025Save 17%
Zom - BEE Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee

Zom-BEE Plushie

Sale price$10.00Regular price $12.00

Handmade Plushies at 99% Coffee

From adorable cats and whales to magical dragons and unicorns, there's truly something for everyone!

All plushies are, unless otherwise stated:

  • Handcrafted in Illinois, U.S. and shipped from Sycamore
  • Made solely by Savannah on a one-by-one basis (find out more about Savannah on the about page!)
  • Made with Premium 100% Polyester
  • Filled with super soft, squishy Polyfill
  • Shipped in compostable envelope mailers (smaller items) or recyclable boxes (larger items) with 100% recyclable packing materials 
  • Customizable with different eye options (standard vs. safety eyes), unless otherwise specified and name options, or even more!

See More at 99% Coffee:

All ProductsHandmade PlushiesAccessoriesCrochet PatternsSafety Eyes