Free shipping on orders over $75

New
Whale Plushie, Mini - Cute Handmade Small Whale Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_group
Vendor:99% Coffee

Whale Stuffed Animal, Mini

$8.00
New Colors
Manta Ray Plushie - Cute Handmade Sting Ray Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_group
Vendor:99% Coffee

Manta Ray Stuffed Animal

$13.00
New
Shark Plushie, Mini - Cute Handmade Small Shark Stuffed Animal Keychain - 99% Coffee - #color_group
Vendor:99% Coffee

Shark Stuffed Animal, Mini

$8.00
Whale Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee
Vendor:99% Coffee

Whale Stuffed Animal, Small

$11.00
Chubby Axolotl Stuffed Animal - Cute Handmade Small Axolotl Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_blue
Vendor:99% Coffee

Chubby Axolotl Stuffed Animal

$15.00
Chubby Mallard Duck Stuffed Animal - Cute Handmade Duck Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_mallard
Vendor:99% Coffee

Chubby Mallard Duck Stuffed Animal

$15.00
Shark Plushie, Small - Cute Handmade Small Shark Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_grey
Vendor:99% Coffee

Shark Stuffed Animal, Small

$11.00
Customizable Loaf Cat Plushie, Tabby - Cute Handmade Custom Cat Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_group

Build a Custom Cat Plushie

Choose your coat pattern, eye color, and name to create your own custom kitty!

Build Now
New
Octopus Plushie, Mini - Handmade Squid, Octopus Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_group
Vendor:99% Coffee

Octopus Stuffed Animal, Mini

$8.00
New
Butterfly Dragon Plushie - Handmade Large Butterfly Dragon Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_green-butterfly
Vendor:99% Coffee

Butterfly Dragon Stuffed Animal

$160.00
New
Octopus Plushie - Handmade Tentacle Octopus Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_green
Vendor:99% Coffee

Octopus Stuffed Animal

$60.00
New
Strawberry Turtle Plushie - Cute Handmade Fruit Turtle Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_strawberry
Vendor:99% Coffee

Strawberry Turtle Stuffed Animal

$44.00

Shop the Market

Check out some of the previous market events!

Small Brontosaurus Stuffed Animal - Handmade Dinosaur Stuffed Animal - 99% Coffee - #color_pink
99% Coffee @ Let's Get Lit Night Market in Rochelle, Illinois hosted by the Artists' Garden

Why 99% Coffee?

When you shop with 99% Coffee, you're supporting a small, handmade business local to Illinois! here's a few other upsides:

Customer Service

Have a problem? Use our live chat feature or email us on the contact us page! Responses will be within 1-2 business days.

Fast Shipping

With fulfillment estimates currently at 1-5 business days, your order will be on its way quickly!

Handmade, Quality Products

All plushies are handmade in Sycamore, Illinois on a one-by-one basis by Savannah.

Customizable Plushies

Need something customized? No problem! Most of plushies have customizations available!
Quick links
Information
© 2025 99% Coffee. Powered by Shopify
  • Amazon
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa